A large portion of Jackie Chan’s fanbase has spent much of the last 10 years hoping for the action legend to take on more drama focused, age-appropriate roles, versus the constant rehashing of his stunt filled glory days. Then, in the 2020’s, it seemed like he finally started to listen. But, as the expression goes, there’s just no pleasing some people. Even when Chan has started to take on more serious roles, such as his aging stuntman turn in 2023’s Ride On, there are those who still find something to complain about. Chief amongst the guilty – me. Look, I’m just as happy to see the 70+ years old version of Jackie Chan who’s willing to take on more dramatic fare as the next guy. My problem is the combination of Chinese cinema’s distinctive brand of saccharine sentimentality, and Chan’s role choices leaning towards those of flawed father figures, tend to leave an odd taste in the mouth.
That combination is at the fore of his latest outing Unexpected Family, which sees Chan teamed with debut director and writer Taiyan Li (credited simply as Tai). The story focuses on Chan’s former weightlifting coach, who discovers his memory issues aren’t connected to his daily drinking habit, but rather are the result of Alzheimer’s disease. In parallel, we meet a small-town youth who’s looking to escape his personal issues, played by Peng Yuchang (An Elephant Sitting Still), who ends up crossing paths with Chan while passing through Wuhan to pick up some casual work. In his confused state, Chan believes Yuchang to be his estranged son and, upon deciding that the best approach will be to go along with it, the local garage owner with whom Chan is acquainted pays Yuchang to play the role. Hijinks ensue, life lessons will be learnt, and there’ll be more back lit, soft-focus shots of smiling faces than you can shake a stick at.
The rest of the Unexpected Family who comprise the supporting cast consist of the previously mentioned garage owner, played by Pan Binlong (Jian Bing Man), the upstairs neighbour, played by Li Ping (Soul Mate), and a young health supplement seller, played by Karlina Zhang (The Struggle of 80’s). Once they learn of Chan’s diagnosis they band together to do what they can for him, often in a way that feels closer to State commissioned productions like My Country, My Parents and My People, My Homeland than any semblance of reality, while of course also learning to overcome their own life challenges. The narrative for the most parts takes a predictable path, with Yuchang spending much of the first half looking for ways to swindle Chan out of his money, especially when he learns Chan still has a savings account for his son that hasn’t been touched for years.
Cue an abundance of misplaced comedy involving the Alzheimer’s diagnosis. The perfect example unfolds when the pair visit the bank to empty the savings account, a sequences which sees Chan switch back and forth as he recognises Yuchang as his son one minute, and doesn’t the next, raising the bank staff’s suspicions. By the time he settles on thinking Yuchang is his son, the bank staff are in the middle of attempting to apprehend him, which gives Chan the opportunity to partake in a minor action scene as he blocks the staff from getting their hands on Yuchang. The setup feels clunky and forced, which when combined with the melodramatic undertones, fails miserably at anyone hoping for Unexpected Family to represent an evolution of Chan’s onscreen persona.
It’s the latter which acts as one of the biggest barriers to being invested in Chan’s acting performance, much like it did for Ride On. In the earlier production though it was less noticeable since Chan was essentially acting as a fictionalised version of himself, whereas in Unexpected Family the acting chops that made him a convincing presence in the likes of Heart of the Dragon and Shinjuku Incident are nowhere to be seen. The biggest issue is the inescapable feeling that Chan isn’t trying to create a character here like he was in the rare ventures into serious territory earlier in his career, but rather he’s attempting to project a version of himself onto audiences that simply doesn’t convince. Watching Chan telling Yuchang “Everything about you is important” after a car accident is more cringe inducing than touching, with Chan’s recent run of father figure roles feeling more like someone who has regrets attempting to make up for them.
Which also creates the catch-22 biggest problem for Chan’s latest – his character is both the least interesting and least likeable thing about it. All 4 of his surrogate family members are far more interesting, however we criminally get to know hardly anything about them. Exactly why Yuchang has ended up in Wuhan is never really explored. The fact that Zhang keeps on ignoring her phone whenever it rings hints at an interesting sub-plot that never materialises. Binlong apparently has a shady past, with Chan having set him on the straight and narrow (of course), but it’s a past which is only spoken of in dialogue and hardly connects to the portrayal onscreen. What we’re left with is a group of poorly defined supporting characters who could have been so much more, but instead are left to flounder around Chan’s increasingly deteriorating condition.
It’s clear that as a first-time director Li doesn’t yet have the experience to extract a nuanced performance out of Chan, with the advancement of his dementia representing the same level of onscreen annoyance as Donnie Yen attempting to find his son in Polar Rescue. This is a movie where advanced dementia is represented as Chan aggressively attempting to eat a tablecloth (because he believes the pictures of fruit that adorn it are real) while wetting himself. Watch as he makes a nuisance of himself in a care home, believing that the staff are attempting to stop him from attending a weightlifting competition. Fight back the tears as he has a seemingly allergic reaction to the sight of a blank DVD, demanding it be removed from his sight. What should be emotionally hard-hitting moments unfortunately fail to register as anything more than Jackie Chan overacting.
For the piece de resistance proceedings truly derail during the final half hour in which, having just been told external stimulation can worsen an Alzheimer’s patient’s condition, Chan’s surrogate family make the decision to rent out a sports hall and recreate the 1995 weightlifting competition that his son took part in. A minor script oversight? The scenario will allow Chan to once more see “the Chinese flag be lifted abroad” and witness someone win who has “black hair and yellow skin”. The whole setup is of course, pointless, as apart from it being a lie, by this point chances are he won’t even remember it the following day. However, while at no point is it mentioned in the movie itself, since there needs to be some kind of plot logic let’s assume that instilling a sense of Chinese pride has a medical benefit of easing dementia symptoms.
The event also serves as the finale of Unexpected Family, offering up an awkward concoction of physical comedy, horrendous flashback sequences consisting of Chan in an unflattering black wig, and an extra syrupy dose of histrionic filled crying from everyone onscreen. As expected, and in perhaps a case of offscreen wish fulfilment, Chan gets to reconcile with his onscreen son through the filter of his dementia, offering up a conclusion that’s only really notable for its distinct lack of catharsis.
Not even the closing credits offer a respite from the jarring tone, which continue the theme that the likes of Ride On and Panda Plan established with Chan referencing his earlier work, as we see him sat in a cinema watching a scene from Miracles before declaring “Why does that guy look like me!?” If that sounds like comedy gold then Unexpected Family may be the movie for you, however for everyone else, far from what the title suggests, Chan’s latest offers up everything we’ve come to expect from his latter-day output. Unfortunately, unlike his golden era, delivering on those expectations is no longer a reason to celebrate.
Paul Bramhall’s Rating: 4/10















This movie could have been more than the final result, but unfortunately, the powers that be thought that this was a winning formula that would tug at everyone’s heart strings.
It can be a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” case of portraying someone with a deteriorating condition since it may be important to show the negative aspects of it, but it shouldn’t make the audience cringe.
Considering how much Chinese cinema loves those over-melodramatic soap opera “woe is everyone” themes with non stop crying, Unexpected Family was not going to get away from that.
I kind of want to see Jackie Chan attempt to eat a tablecloth while drenched in his own piss but I’m sure the mental image is funnier than the actual film sequence.
Any movie that draw comparisons with Polar Rescue aka Come Back Home aka Doooonnniiiieee’s worst movie since The Monkey King 1 , is in big trouble. And while my appetite for melodrama is bigger than most, even this movie was pushing it.
Totally unrelated have you seen V aka The Empty Gun. For those that can only glaze China and say theres no such thing as censorship , go watch this movie and say it again with a straight face. For the first 2/3rd it plays like a cover version of all your favourite country bumpkin makes it big in Hong Kong triad crime tropes. And its actually pretty decent like a decent cover song should be. The main actor has the strangest Cantonese accent i’ve heard in a while but that just adds to the charm of the movie. Unfortuantely, the last third switches genres and it becomes one of those painful to watch China number 1 best police in the world movies. Not even the insult about the Guangxi accent can save the last hour of the movie.